Previous Entry Share Next Entry
Game of Thrones
plushfish
fishsupreme
So, today's (okay, yesterday's, I'm a day behind) prompt was Game of Thrones -- without spoilers. I'll do my best.

[personal profile] anjelabug and I have been reading A Song of Ice and Fire since the first novel, A Game of Thrones, came out many years ago. I remember picking up the third book in New Zealand in 2005, since it was published while we were on vacation.

As a result, we were really looking forward to the show before it even came out, especially with Sean Bean cast as Eddard Stark. And by and large the show has been excellent; it's certainly the best TV adaptation of a fantasy novel/series ever. The casting has been very good (I have no idea how they were so fortunate as to cast so many good child actors), and it's been mostly faithful to the novels -- certainly faithful enough that for most of the series we book-readers have known what's going to happen, usually well enough to be watching our non-book-reading friends with great amusement when we know that some catastrophe is about to befall a main character.

And do they ever. Martin certainly doesn't shy away from killing his characters.

I like the complexity of the storyline, and the way the background and history is slowly unveiled as we go along. I like the variety of the viewpoints, and how events can turn even some of the most evil characters into sympathetic ones as the story progresses -- though they seldom manage to outrun the things they've done. And mostly I just really enjoy reading about some of the very interesting people Martin's come up with -- both major characters like Arya and Tyrion and minor ones like Varys the Spider (who has some very interesting commentary on the nature of power.)

It has its faults, too. For one, Martin's decision to split the last two books by character instead of chronology resulted in a lot of "filler" chapters for some characters in which not much happened. This was a change from previous books where in almost every chapter you were sad to see it end and the viewpoint change. Regarding the HBO show and the changes made to adapt the books to the screen, I think that the inability to see what's in the main characters' heads makes some of the plots not work as well, and I question how the producers of the show could possibly have read A Song of Ice and Fire and decided it needed more rape in it. Some of the changes also seem kind of random -- renaming certain characters, merging others, etc. -- and I'm not sure why they made them since it would have been no more difficult to just film the scenes as written, and sometimes these are going to cause problems along the line (i.e. early changes to a "minor" character might end up a problem if Martin makes that character more important later, which he's done before.)

All in all, though, it's a very enjoyable show and with the squad of nerds I have as friends has led to a ton of interesting conversations.

This entry was originally posted at http://fishsupreme.dreamwidth.org/70871.html. Please comment there using OpenID.

  • 1

Aw, crap, I should have clarified. I'm all caught up on GoT -- it was more in comments or if you're introducing me to another TV show that I didn't want to be spoiled.

This is a GREAT discussion of books vs. the show. Which characters, for you, are the most perfectly cast?

We love Arya and Tyrion, although I've always had a soft spot for Sansa.

SPOILERS START HERE

Watching her learn to deal with the horrible people she's been stuck with. Seeing her begin to take the offensive has been very exciting. I'm also very fond of Margaery and her skillful "How to Win Friends and Influence People"-style manipulations.

I'm also baffled by the decisions of the TV show to turn scenes into rape that were clearly not rape in the book (I'm thinking of Danaerys's consummation and the altar scene). They completely changed those scenes, and it would not have been at all difficult to keep them as-is with a few lines of dialogue. It almost seems like there's a rape-happy producer on the show. >:(

Re: I'VE GOT SPOILERS

Well, clearly Tyrion is one, as Peter Dinklage's new stardom indicates.

I think my favorite casting choices, though, have been Maisie Williams and Charles Dance. I admit that when reading the books I always pictured Tywin Lannister as Malcolm McDowell, but Charles Dance did a fantastic job with the character. Jack Gleeson did a great job as the most insufferable Joffrey Baratheon ever, too.

I love Margaery in the show! Actually, I think she's a case where the show actually did a much better job fleshing out a character than the books ever did. The books don't give you nearly as much Margaery to go on -- she could be the awesome schemer of the show, but you don't know for sure. But the way show-Margaery accepted Renly as for who he was, and the way she morphed from "seductress" to "playmate" as she felt out Tommen's personality were both incredible to see.

Edited at 2014-07-10 04:03 am (UTC)

  • 1
?

Log in